Wednesday, August 5, 2015

Slow down the teaching to speed up the learning

The title of this post was a line we heard A LOT last year, and at the time we were all thinking, "what is that supposed to mean?!??" I think I get it now. I've recently read Make It Stick, by Peter Brown, followed a Twitter chat about the book, and I'm continuing to read blog posts by other teachers about how they're going to use what the book taught them, and I finally understand what our admin meant by that line.
I use to stress about grading. We had 80 minute classes, to keep middle schoolers focused we (the sixth grade math teachers) broke our class time up into three chunks, add in homework and I could easily have 2 or 3 new assignments to grade each day (because if it wasn't graded, our students wouldn't do it). That's about 400 assignments over the course of a year. It was overwhelming.
I think what our admin meant was for us to do higher level questions, take more time for students to discuss their work and different ways of approaching a problem, explore how a problem might be extended, reflect on their thought processes and work, and revise their work. Instead of spending 25 minutes on 8 basic process problems we should have spent 1 or 2 whole classes working on a handful of deep questions.
Hindsight is 20/20, right? The awesome part about being a teacher is being able to start fresh each August and learn from our past mistakes, so that's what I plan to do :)

Here are some things I want to do:
1. Explicitly teach students how to take notes. I've gone to AVID training, so I can share Cornell Notes with them. I've don't interactive notebooks for a few years, so I can show them that way of being organized and making notes engaging. And I've pinned a few things on teaching students how to take notes. Now I just need to not stress about time and take a day or two (or three) to teach students how to organize and use what they're taught in class.
2. Give students time to reflect. Without time to reflect, how can I expect students to learn from their mistakes, or learn in general? I need to give them time to connect what we're learning to what they already know as well as any real life applications. I don't think they'll be use to this in math class, so I'll need to come up with a list of questions or sentence stems they can use to guide their thinking. One thing that might help with the building connections part would be AVID one-pagers; students get a blank sheet of paper, colored pencils, pens, pencils, etc. and summarize/connect/draw what they learned. Here is an example of a proportions one-pager:
Anna at TypeAMathLand.blogspot.com mentioned having a summary sheet in their notebooks at the end of each unit, and I LOVE the idea. I'm thinking of making the sheet an assignment/homework two days before each test, so students can come to review days (assuming I have time to take a day before each test to review) knowing what topics they need more time working with. 
I saw the idea somewhere (if it was your idea please let me know so I can give you credit!) of letting students grade their own tests using an answer key and a unique colored pen. I'm not sure I want them looking at test answer keys, but I plan to continue doing weekly checks of understanding (read: quizzes, but we didn't call them quizzes) and I think this would be a good time for them to figure out where (and why) they went wrong. This would help them (and me) see instantly what they know and what they need to review more.
3. Give students time to revisit and revise their work. Half the value of feedback is students being able to correct what they got wrong. I'm not sure what type of assignment(s) I want to do this for, but I want to give students a chance to make corrections after getting feedback but before its formally graded. Feedback might come from a peer, a group, or me, but I want to give students a chance to correct misconceptions before I assess their understanding and give it a grade. I know I won't have the time to look at each assignment twice, even if I do some peer checking, so I want to be sure to implement this where it'll have the greatest impact.
4. Continue spiral review activities, and make tests spiral as well. A big point of Make It Stick was mixed review and revisiting a topic days/weeks/months later. The school I was at required we do a spiral review activity each day, so interleaving (as it's called in the book) is something I'm very familiar with, but I think I need to do more than just one activity. I see homeworks being a mixed review, not including any problems on the topic covered that day (again, an idea I can't remember where I got it from; let me know if it's yours), and tests including items from previous units. I think this last part will go well with the standars-based grading hybrid I did last year (and plan to do this year); these old-unit questions will be optional and will be the topics the most students have low grades for. If students choose to attempt these problems they can replace their current grade on the topic. One thing I struggled to decide on last year, and I can use some input on for this year, is whether newer lower grades should replace older higher grades. This past year I always kept the highest grade a student earned on a learning target, assuming that lower grades were a product of having a bad day or making a silly mistake. I figured if a student could earn an A (which was a real challenge) on a learning target at one point they had to have a real understanding of a topic, and any newer lower grades were due to issues besides not understanding.

In summary, I think that spending more time working on, reflecting on, and fixing higher quality questions would allow me to slow down the teaching to speed up the learning. Thanks for reading my brain dump! And thank you Anna for your post that lead to this eureka moment! Any feedback/advice anyone can give would be greatly appreciated!

Blaugust Challenge Post #2

I meant to do this post yesterday, but it was the last day of a family trip and I drove back so I didn't get the chance. I'm going to try rewriting my original Baugust Post #1; 20 facts about me.

1. I grew up in Ohio.
2. I moved to North Carolina after college to get away from Ohio weather.
3. I've spent the last three years teaching sixth grade math; this year will be my first year teaching high school.
4. I want to go back to school for a Master's, but I'm not sure yet what I want to study.
5. I got my cat from Craig's list when I was in college- I wanted a pet and it was easier to take care of a kitten than a puppy. His name's Kolby; I named him after an adorable 6 year old kid I had in summer camp who sang Beatles songs.
6. I LOVE traveling- I've been to 11 countries and 21 states.
7. I LOVE reading- my favorite is historical fiction.
8. I'm a horrible cook- I've managed to burn no-bake cookies and easy mac :/
9. I rarely eat meat, I never eat seafood, and I never drink milk or (nor?) pop
10. My favorite show is Walking Dead and I'm super excited to see the spin off series.
11. I've wanted to be a teacher since kindegarten, but I was in seventh grade when I decided I wanted to teach math.
12. My favorite math topic is a tie between algebra and statistics.
13. I started playing piano when I was 10 and continued playing instruments until I graduated high school.
14. I had stitches three times as a kid.
15. I have 1  2/3 tattoos. My second one isn't complete; where I get the last piece done is just as important as the tattoo itself.
16. In college I was in a program called Camp Adventure; they trained us and sent us to military bases around the world to run childcare services. For under $5000 total I spent 12 weeks in Japan, 15 weeks in Key West, 3 weeks in Italy, and 10 weeks in Boston.
17. I have 2 to 3 cups of coffee every morning, if I don't have coffee I get a migraine that afternoon.
18. Last school year was rough and I considered switching to be an ITF (Instructional Technology Facilitator).
19. I've never been good at playing sports, I lack the coordination.
20. My first job in high school was working in a candy shop. My second job was working at an amusement park.

To join the Blaugust challenge check out the prompts at statteacher.blogspot.com, and be sure to share your post on Twitter using #MTBoSBlaugust.

Monday, August 3, 2015

Blaugust Challenge Post #1

So I just finished typing up this post when the app crashed and it completely disappeared 😭
I had originally written for the "20 facts about yourself" prompt, but after the crash I'm feeling defeated and don't want to type it all again, so I'll come back to that prompt later and instead I'll respond to prompts 6 and 7. (For the list of prompts visit statteacher.blogspot.com)

First is "One time in math class... (as a teacher)". So last year I had a student that had a very big personality, and his other teachers and I spend a lot of time teaching him when it was ok to be funny and when it wasn't appropriate. By the third quarter he had things pretty much under control. One day I was at the board leading the class through an example and I called on that student (he was just over my shoulder, so chances are I was just making sure he was on task, I don't remember exactly). I do remember turning and looking over my shoulder at him- waiting for an answer- and he must not have heard me call on him because I turn to see him doing a little dance in his seat (pencil in hand, looking at his sheet), snapping his fingers, and very quietly singing (now keep in mind everyone else has heard me call on him, so the whole class is watching and waiting for his answer) "you know what to do with that big fat butt... wiggle wiggle wiggle". We all bust out laughing and he looks up with the most surprised/shocked face I've ever seen, he had no idea we were watching him; I swear I'll never forgot his face in that moment. It was one of those times I couldn't help laughing, and he was an easy-going kid so he laughed along with us. It became an inside joke with that class and helped me remember that it's just as important to laugh with my kids as it is to cover all the standards.

Now for my "One time in math class... (as a student)". It was seventh grade when I realized it was math I wanted to teach. I'd always known I wanted to be a teacher, but up to that point I had no idea what I wanted to teach. We were learning about volume and surface area. Our teacher gave us each a little box of nerds to eat while we took notes, but we had to be very careful with the boxes. After the notes she had us measure the nerds boxes, then find the surface area and volume. We worked in groups, and I remember a lot of my friends were struggling to find the surface area; the top and bottom of each box has four flaps and they were counting both long flaps on the top and both on the bottom. I struggled to get them to understand that for surface area you only needed one of the long flaps on top, and one on the bottom. So I took them to the side one by one until each of them understood. Seeing the lightbulb go on and helping them understand is what convinced me I wanted to be a math teacher; I loved math and loved helping others understand.

If you're not already writing for the Blaugust challenge you should join us, and don't forgot to share your post on Twitter using #MTBoSBlaugust!

Wednesday, June 24, 2015

Keep, Change, Start, Stop

Our last day of school was two weeks ago... I can't believe its already been two weeks! I'm trying to be very aware of every day this summer, so at the end I don't feel like I've taken it for granted; for example, if we were still in school right now I'd be in the middle of my second class for the day. I'm also trying to do something five days a week, so I don't feel like I wasted my time.

My big to-do is getting ready for next year. I'm switching from teaching sixth grade to teaching high school. Right now the plan is two Math I courses and one Math II Honors course first semester, and two Math II courses and one Math II Honors second semester. I'm liking the idea that this time next year I will have taught and tweaked Math II Honors twice. I have a friend that teaches science as a semester class in seventh grade, and I'm envious that she gets more opportunities to complete her curriculum and make improvements.

So, without further ado, I'd like to talk about what I want to Keep, Change, Start and Stop...


Keep


  • "Interactive" Notebook- I love the organization of us all being on the same page, and knowing exactly where to direction a student when they're struggling (even better, when a student uses it without prompting!). They're not very interactive (I don't do many foldables) but that's something I'll need to work on at some point.
  • Class Jobs- I might have to do some modifying of what jobs are available, but I LOVE having the extra help around class. My most used class job was group leaders; group leaders would help me pass out and collect things throughout class. I handed them each (three in each class) a small stack of papers and they passes them out. They also collected papers at the end of class, so I didn't have 27 students trying to turn in their paper in at the same time. Another job that seems minor, but I loved having, was door monitor. They didn't really monitor the door, but whenever we went anywhere (we had to walk as a class everywhere, and I had to escort them) I had one student responsible for closing the door when everyone was out of the room.
  • Class Economy- Part of my classroom management was a class store. Students earned points for behaving, doing class jobs, doing extra work, or helping me. Students could redeem this points for supplies and rewards in my class store. I had a link to a pdf of the "prices" for each item on my class website, and I also created a google form they used to submit an order. I think this is one of the reasons my classes ran so smoothly; students loved earning points and were super cooperative.

Change

  • Standards Based Grading- I want to keep the idea that grades are reported by learning target, but in a district that's still on a 0-100, A-F scale its a huge stresser trying to grade based on understanding. So I want to continue to break up grades by skill, but each question will be worth two points (one for showing work, one for correct answer) and grades will be calculated normally.
  • Notes- This past year my goal was to do cornell notes, and I started out the year doing so, but it faded away. I tried letting up control, and putting more responsibility on the students, but they didn't keep up with it and I didn't enforce it. I'm not sure if I'll do cornell notes again this year, but I have found some awesome pins about explicitly teaching students how to take notes and I am going to do that, in some form.

Start

  • Daily reflections of lessons- I found my lesson plans from my first year. Man, were they detailed! AND I reflected on each lesson each day!! I think that stopped when I stopped printing my lessons and didn't have a pretty blank box staring at me everyday. This year I bought a lesson plan book (this past year I used a google spreadsheet); I'm trying hand written lessons and I want to start reflection again each day.
  • Teaching high school- This seems like a duh, at this point, but with switching districts, schools, grades, standards, I think one Start is enough.

Stop

  • Talking so much- I think I talk too much sometimes and my words are losing their value.
  • Grading everything- Ok, I've gotten away from grading EVERYTHING, but I still grade too much. I'm not sure if that's just part of being a math teacher (my ELA, Science and Social Studies friends don't grade nearly as much as I do) or if I'm over doing it. I'll have to find someone (more multiple people) in the math department at my new school with more experience and find out what they do.

Sunday, August 17, 2014

MTBoS Challenge Week 1


3 Things I Want To Continue From Last Year
1. Weekly goals for failing students- this will need a bit of modification, since I'll be doing a SBG hybrid, but similar to last year, failing students will be given a slip of paper with their current failing grade and their goal grade (+5%). They have a week to meet this goal or they call home to let their parents know they're failing and will be bringing home a progress report to be signed. The slip with their goal also had a list of 1-5 assignments on which they have an F. I noticed this specific goal, deadline, and means of reacting the goal help students make progress.
2. Interactive Notebooks- my students last year LOVED the organized and predicatable set up, table of contents and flippables in their notebooks. We were constantly referencing their notebooks and looking back to old skills they needed to refresh.
3. Rotations- last year each of my classes were broken up into three groups and they rotated through the activities each day. They were grouped by ability shown on pre-test and the activities were usually spiral review, notes, and teacher time. This allowed me to work with 1/3 of each class at a time, so each student got more one on one attention and I better knew the understanding of each student.

2 New Things I Want To Try This Year
1. Standards Based Grading Hybrid- there are some assignments I still want to bear weight on their grade, so I'm not going completely SBG, but 80% of their grade will be SBG. I'm a little nervous of the workload this will add, and how to explain it to parents/students, but the concept of students/parents/me knowing what skills students need more practice with- not assignments- just seems like common sense.
2. Cornell Notes- this is a notes organization created by AVID that lends itself nicely to review/studying

1 Goal For This Year
1. My highest goal for this year is that 80% of my students meet or exceed their expected growth this year. At the beginning of the year we are given the score students need to get on the end of grade test to have made a year's worth of growth. As of right now I'll have about 85 students, half of which will be identified as gifted in math. I anticipate my biggest struggle actually being with my gifted students; when a student comes to you at the 98th percentile, that doesn't leave a lot of room for growth.


I am trying this year to link up each week with the #MTBoSChallenge. I am new to blogging (and twitter) so we'll see how this goes. 

Monday, July 21, 2014

A Journey Into a Standards Based Grading Hybrid- Part 1

I'm a bit obsessive and have spent way too many hours reading every blog, tweet, research paper, etc. I could about standards based grading. It is summer after all, so I've got spades of time. I want to start by saying I absolutely LOVE the concept of standards based grading (or SBG for short). It makes perfect sense and I'm flabbergasted that I haven't heard anything about it before (I only graduated from my undergrad 3 years ago), and just happen to stumble across it this summer. My first exposure was from this blog, which led me to this blog, which spelled it out in the level of detail I wanted/needed (including posts on how to apply it to different subjects!).
This is one of those times I hate being a 6th grade teacher; since we're at the middle school and 5th grade is at the 4 feeder elementary schools we get minimal information about the students we're to have, and since these kids are being blended into one school for the first time issues could pop up where they didn't exist before. What we have heard is that next year's class is just as lazy as last year's class (and last year's class was VERY lazy) and they're very immature (prone to whining and crying). But even knowing that, I blame my greenness for my ideology that this year my class will run perfectly; every activity will run smoothly, all my students will love me and do all their work, they'll learn everything I teach them, and unicorns will prance around below blue skies and rainbows (that last one was a bit sarcastic, but you get the idea). Throw into the mix that I'll be teaching two AIG (academically intellectually gifted) classes and one regular class this year (I have only ever taught regular classes), and I think I'm going to go with a SBG hybrid model. I'm not comfortable jumping all in from the beginning. Here are my notes on what I've learned from others with a few musings of my own, let me know what you think.

1) Grades for my regular class will be 10% from Clipboard Math (a spiral review activity our students work on every day), 10% from notes (questions answered in eduCanon videos and reflection bookmarks completed once a unit), 80% SBG. Grades for my AIG students will be 7% Clipboard Math, 7% notes, 6% superstar homework (check out this link for the 6th grade series, it's problem-solving/higher-order-thinking practice), 80% SBG.

2) Assessments for SBG will be discussions in class, the final exit ticket for an LT, weekly quizzes, unit tests. Our district gives a "benchmark test" at the end of each quarter, I'm not sure if or how this will factor into their grade.

3) SBG will be on a 0-10 scale I got from here. 10 is advanced (can only be achieved by earning two or more 9's), 8-9 is proficient (wiggle room for little computation errors, missing label, etc.), 6-7 is basic, 0-5 below basic. 1 is they started the problem but didn't get far (underlined correct key words, messed around with the numbers a bit but obviously had no idea what they were doing). 0 is they didn't do anything with the problem.
I'm going with a 10 point scale because my district (and our required grade book system) is based on percentages. If it's a 4 point scale, and 3 means proficient, I don't want that showing up as a 75% in the grade book. Especially since we're on a 7 point grading scale, so 75% is a D. Yikes! Proficient canNOT be a D. My AIG parents would be freaking out, blowing up my email and phone, and stampeding my room for a change.

4) If a student has a 0 on a LT I contact their parents and tutor them during lunch; there's no excuse for getting a 0. This tells me they're either so lost they need immediate intervention, or so lazy they won't even pick up their pencil. And either they need a lot of 1-on-1 support or they need a lesson that actions (or inaction) have consequences, and if they waste my class time I will take their social time to make it up.

5) LT grades will not go down if they don't do as well on a later assessment. This is the part that has made me do the most thinking. I can understand why some people allow their LT grades to go down, it reflects the student's most current understanding of a target. My thoughts on that are first, what if they had a bad day, and that's why they did poorly on the second assessment. Most people would say, "Well, then they practice and see me for a re-assessment." That would add to my number of re-assessments exponentially, it would be more than I could handle, especially my first year at this. Second, if their grade is to show how well they understand a target, and at one point they were proficient, I don't see the benefit of punishing them for forgetting a few things. Honestly, this is 6th grade math, and some of my students don't know where they're going to sleep tonight or where they're going to get their next meal, so in that context what does it matter if they went down 2 or even 5 points on a topic.
I want their grade to show me what they have been able to push their minds to do. I need to have faith that my assessments are truly measuring their level, then I won't have to question that the earlier higher grade was a fluke. My plan, in exchange, is to keep track of their level progression for each LT. So maybe their level for dividing fractions went 5/7/8/7/6. In cases like this where they're showing quite a bit of forgetfulness I'll have a conversation with the student about how well they truly feel they understand the topic and why their score has been slipping. If it's an isolated target I might just give them a practice activity to work through and then we'll discuss it, if it's a pattern and they're truly declining I'll contact parents about what we need to do to provide that student with more support.

6) Homework- except for superstars- will be provided but not required. I will also be giving students the answers to the problems. I want homework to be about practicing skills. If they have the answers they know instantly if they're doing it right or wrong. The next day for the warm up we can discuss any issues they had. While this isn't completely an SBG thing, it's new to me, and I'm worried about it. As I mentioned, my students next year have a history of laziness, and I'm afraid that if it's not graded they won't do it. In the past I have tried making homework optional (now granted, I didn't give them the answers) and practically no one even looked at it, even my best students admitted to it. And I know they'll have a lot of required homework from their other teachers...

So, what do you think about all this? Have I lost my mind?

Tuesday, July 1, 2014

AVID- preparing the "middle" for college

I have just finished my second year of teaching, and both years have been at the same school. I went to a national conference last week and discovered some things that are normal and run-of-the-mill for me are not for other districts. So, on that basis, I want to talk to you about a program called AVID.
AVID is an acronym (Advancement Via Individual Determination) and the program is dedicated to those students in the middle; the ones who are often overlooked because they're not constantly struggling and not pushing the boundaries of our curriculum. These students are, on average, B or C students who want to go to college but are the first in their family. The AVID program is designed to start in elementary school, teaching students the skills needed (note-taking, organization, prioritization, etc.) to do well in school. In middle school, skills can be taught school-wide, but the focus is on a core group of students (about 20-25 per grade level) who continue working on skills in core classes that will help them progress to college AND they take an AVID elective class that focuses on those skills as well as beginning to look at colleges and what it'll take to get into one. Then in high school students continue with the AVID elective class and they help students prepare for college (applications, tours, interviews, etc.). There is also a piece of the AVID program that continues into higher education, but I don't know anything about it.
This conference I went to last week was an AVID conference. I went with about 40 other people from my school district to the 3-day, 5000-participant, conference in Dallas and it was AMAZING! We spent about half our time working with our site team (the group of people from our school who would be responsible for implementing and evaluating the AVID program at our school), and the other half was spent working on AVID techniques with other teachers from our content area (so I was with 60 other math teachers). The first part I loved about the conference was that they had a Math 1 and a Math 2 strands. So people who did Math 1 last year went to Math 2 this year, so they could take it a step further and not hear the same things they did last year.
At the end of the conference we did an activity in our math strand called Give One, Take One. We took three post-it notes and on each post-it we wrote a different strategy we want to try using in the next school year. We also wrote when we wanted to have tried each strategy by, our name, and our email address. We swapped post-its with three people and are responsible for contacting those people to see how they did with the strategy they gave us. I'm not sure I just did a good job explaining the whole process, but here are the three strategies I hope to implement this year:
1) Sentence Frames- the one thing I LOVED about this strategy was how it will especially help our ELL (English Language Learner) students. The leaders of our session focused on using this strategy with vocabulary. You basically give students a sentence with blanks for missing pieces, but my Ah-Ha! moment was when they said the blanks should be where numbers would go, NOT words. Let's look at an example:
       The _________ of 36 is 6.
       The square root of ____ is ____.
The first sentence frame has a blank where "square root" should be, and the only thing that would fit in that blank is square root; that's a very limited sentence and doesn't lead to individualization. But the second sentence frame could be completed in any number of ways; the student could put 4 and 2, 9 and 3, 225 and 15 or any square (perfect or not) and its square root! Awesome, right?! This idea took sentence frames to a whole new level for me, and I want to use it this year in my class room. My students do Frayer Models for vocabulary, and one of the boxes is Word in a Sentence, and I will use a sentence frame in each Frayer Model. It was on one of my post-it notes, and I think I put October as when I would like to have tried it by; so I'm expecting an email in October asking how sentence frames is going for me.
2) Cornell Notes- If you have not heard of Cornell notes (or c-notes) I HIGHLY suggest you do some research. It's a method of taking notes that pushes students to be more mentally involved, instead of just mindlessly copying the teacher. At the top right students put their name, date and core/period (I won't be doing this part because my students will be using a notebook, but this would be good for classes where notes are taken on loose-sleeve paper and organized in a binder). To the left of that they put the topic and objective (for me this will be the title of the notes and the standard). Below all that they put the "essential question(s)" ( which are the question(s) they should be able to answer after finishing the notes on that page; I am changing the name to "topic question" because our county uses the name "essential question" in another way). Skip down to the bottom of the page, about 4 or 5 lines are blocked off for the summary. Between the essential questions and the summary a vertical line is drawn about 2 to 2 1/2 inches from the left side of the page. To the right of the line is where the students take their notes, however they or their teacher wants. To the left of the line is where they write their Study Questions.
Here is how C-notes work; students start by filling in the top of the page (teacher provides topic, objective and essential questions). Teacher teaches and students take notes in the Notes box. For homework (or within 8 hours of taking the notes) students go back and modify their notes; crossing out what was not needed, adding extra to fill in any holes. Students also, for homework create the Study Questions; it's kind of like Jeopardy, where the notes are the answers and the students create the questions. So if we took notes about finding area of rectangles they would have the steps for finding area followed by a few examples. The Study Question for the steps might be "How do I find the area of a rectangle?". The Study Questions for the examples would be the example problem. The idea is students could cover the right side of their page and use the questions on the left to study and quiz themselves. The next day in class, as a warm-up, students would write the summary for the notes at the bottom of the page. Now students have looked at that one set of notes three times, and they are three times as likely to remember the information. Our session leaders told us about GIST Summaries, where students circle/highlight/underline 3-5 important words/phrases from their notes and use those to write a summary of their notes as well as answer the essential question(s) (I think I would use a GIST Summary for homework the second night, so students will have looked at the material four times :)
I think I said I wanted to have tried this by December (I plan on using the layout beginning day 1, but I'm going to guide students in the Study Question process; begin by giving them the questions, then we develop questions together, then they create questions on their own)
Here is a picture of what the Cornell Notes sheet looks like; I found it by googling "Cornell Notes". There are also sheets where the Notes area is blank, and where the Notes area is graph paper.

3) Tutorials- I'm going to start by showing you the Tutorial Request Form (again, I found this by googling "AVID Tutorial Request Form Sample".
In the AVID elective, students have Tutorials twice a week (Tuesdays and Thursdays), but I'm going to tell you how I plan to modify the process for my class.
I plan on doing Tutorials as time allows (there are a few days the first quarter where we will have time to review) and the day before each test. Students will fill out this form (or something similar) 2-3 days before; the question they chose should be a higher level question. I love this form because it makes them pick a question they are struggling with, in a topic they don't fully understand, and really break it down to find out exactly where their confusion is. One of my biggest pet peeves is when I ask a student which part they don't understand and they say, "The whole thing," when in fact it is just one step of the process that is tripping them up. So, this form will help them identify where they are having problems. I will look through the submitted forms and break them up into groups based on similar problems. Each group has about 6 or 7 students and a "tutor" (someone with more knowledge of the topic- an 8th grader, high school/college volunteer, or teacher). The student in each group who feels they need the most help will present their problem. (All groups will be working simultaneously, in different parts of the room, so the student presenting doesn't have to feel like everyone is watching them) The presenter will go up the their group's board and will write their original question, as much work as they can do on their own, and write out their POC (point of confusion). While the confused student is presenting, the tutor will be writing their notes for them, so the student presenting can focus on what they're doing on the board but still have a written log of what was done. Now the cool part is the tutor and other students in the group will help clarify the thinking of the presenter, but can ONLY ask questions such as "do we have notes on this?", "what do our notes say to do next?", "is there something that we can eliminate or that is missing?" The non-presenters in each group focus not on the solution to the problem, but on the presenter's thinking. They keep going until the presenter has an answer they are satisfied with. Since all students in the group struggled with the same concept, each student then writes a summary/reflection of their learning from that problem, and- time allowing- share their summary/reflection with the group. 
We watched a video demo of this at our conference (the video was on completing the square) and the whole process- of working through the problem- took about 20 minutes. To our horror, there was an error in the process (the student was doing b^2/2 not (b/2)^2) and the tutor didn't catch it. The leaders of our session informed us that in this situation the teacher should give the group about 5 minutes to catch the mistake, keep asking questions like "are you sure you're doing the steps in the correct order?" or "do you see an error in your process?". If the presenter doesn't catch their mistake the teacher can take 30 seconds to tell the student their process is wrong and quickly tell the student how to fix it (do not take the pen, let the student do all the writing).
This strategy seems extremely powerful, if utilized correctly, so I'll need to do more research on the process before I implement it in class. On my post-it note I said I want to have used this strategy before May, so I'll have plenty of time to fluently understand the process, explain it to my students, and try it in class.

This conference was extremely useful and I learned more strategies than I know what to do with. In my two short years of teaching I have learned to focus my energy on 2-3 new things each year. I know that if I tried to do it all this year it would be overwhelming and nothing would be done well; but if I focus on just a few new things each year I can really work on perfecting them and fitting them to my class.